I may regret asking this, but I'm curious why the change from "dark Alice" to "dirty Alice"? No reason, just curious.
Also, one comment on the shading/highlighting. I see something which seems inconsistent around the chest area. On her chest, we see the brightest highlights, while the um, bazooms should realistically show the brightest. I think even if the light source was horizontal and in front of her (light from the left), which would maximize the light on the chest, some would still strike the top of the, you know. But with the light coming from behind her (from the right), the chest should be darker than the top of the, you know..
Unless I'm missing something. Which given my experience compared to yours, I probably AM missing something. But on Dark Alice, the highlights seem more as I would expect. I don't know if you made a change, or if it's more of an optical illusion with the lighter background?
Anyway, just a couple of thoughts
Nice colors, btw!